• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Got a Story?
Twitter
Logo
Menu   ≡ ╳
  • News
  • Arts & Culture
  • Sikhi
  • Business
  • History
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • People & Community
  • Matrimonials
Latest:
  • Health & Lifestyle Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic?
  • People and Community British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords
  • News Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India’s Destiny
  • Sikhi Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism’s Rich Heritage
  • Sikhi The Guru Granth Sahib: Sikhism’s Holy Book
  • History When Was the Golden Temple Built – Unveiling the Origins
Bollywood is ‘escapist dross’ says Times writer
Home » News » Bollywood is ‘escapist dross’ says Times writer

Bollywood is ‘escapist dross’ says Times writer

24 July, 2009
News
1936

Many millions of people around the globe watch them at the cinema or on dvd – and appear to enjoy them – but are Bollywood films really “vacuous escapist dross for the masses”?

That’s the view of Sathnam Sanghera, a feature writer with The Times newspaper in Britain, who is developing a reputation for expressing unconventional and challenging opinions (in a book about his family he stood up against the seemingly indestructible Indian convention of the arranged marriage).

 

In today’s Times Sanghera makes a blistering attack on Bollywood movies as afflicted by lipsynching (actors rarely do their own singing), plagiarism of tunes and plots, “rubbish” sound and writing, predictability, and repetitious use of “love triangles, moustachioed villains and star-crossed lovers dancing around trees”.

He also dislikes their melodramatic storylines (citing one example in some detail) and their length, which frequently extends to around three hours.

A witty commentator, Sanghera opines: “There is absolutely no need for anything, apart from sleep, to go on longer than two hours.”

He believes that Bollywood “nonsense” should not be promoted and celebrated to the extent that is today, even though it is successfully infiltrating western entertainment channels from television to pop to film and theatre, as never before.

The West’s cinematic standards exert some influence in the opposite direction – with would-be Bollywood actors also being coached in  acting techniques that will stand them in good stead in the Western  ‘mainstream’. But with more opportunities for Indian actors in Indian films than in Hollywood or Europe this is a limited process.

Bollywood did not always dominate of course. Sanghera points out that in the Fifties and Sixties Indian films portraying the hardships of Indian’s poor regularly competed for best foreign language film nominations at major film festivals in Europe and America. This all went wrong in the seventies, he says.

He is not convinced by suggestions that Bollywood films have improved – even if they win six prizes at the Indian Film Academy awards, as the historical  film Jodhatha Akbar did recently.

You can read Sanghera’s full critique on The Times website at http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/sathnam_sanghera/article6720805.ece

But is he right or is he wrong?  If you like Bollywood movies – what is the allure for you? The music, the dancing? Do you have a favourite film? Or have you been a silent sufferer of the genre for years, not wanting to spoil the enjoyment of family and friends who can’t get their fill?

Is Bollywood perhaps sustained purely and simply by the romanticism of Indian women? If so, what would men prefer to watch? Are they being catered for at all?

We’d love to hear what you have to say. Write and tell us what you think. For – or against!

  • About the Author
  • Latest Posts

About Mann Matharu

Mann Matharu is the Chief Editor and Founder of Sikhs Online. He is responsible for the research into Sikh related stories and marketing of the site.
  • British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords - May 27, 2024
  • Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India’s Destiny - December 26, 2024
  • Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism’s Rich Heritage - July 22, 2023
  • The Guru Granth Sahib: Sikhism’s Holy Book - July 3, 2023
  • When Was the Golden Temple Built – Unveiling the Origins - June 13, 2023
  • Why do Sikhs wear turbans – Sikhs Online - April 18, 2023
  • Navigating Life with Teachings of Guru Nanak - April 6, 2023
  • Kulveer Ranger’s Biography, Wife, Career, Achievements - April 3, 2023
  • Sidhu Moosewala Biography: Height, Age, First Song and More - March 26, 2023
  • The life of Amrita Sher-Gil: India’s Frida Kahlo - April 15, 2020
Mann Matharu
  • Arts and Culture 26
  • Business 10
  • Health & Lifestyle 21
  • History 30
  • News 140
  • People and Community 87
  • Sikh Videos 2
  • Sikhi 15
  • Uncategorized 9
Sikhs Online
- Previous article
« Sikh police in key culture crimes scheme
Sikhs Online
Next article -
Judge hits errant dairy with £200k costs »
  • Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic? Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic?
    December 17
    Health & Lifestyle
  • British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords
    May 27
    People and Community
  • Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India’s Destiny Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India’s Destiny
    December 26
    NewsPeople and Community
  • Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism’s Rich Heritage Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism’s Rich Heritage
    July 22
    Sikhi
  • The Guru Granth Sahib: Sikhism’s Holy Book The Guru Granth Sahib: Sikhism’s Holy Book
    July 3
    Sikhi
  • When Was the Golden Temple Built – Unveiling the Origins When Was the Golden Temple Built – Unveiling the Origins
    June 13
    History

  • Why do Sikhs wear turbans – Sikhs Online

    Why do Sikhs wear turbans – Sikhs Online

    Sikhi
  • Top Ten Things That Inspire Me

    Top Ten Things That Inspire Me

    Health & LifestylePeople and Community
  • Meet The Woman Behind London Finance Solutions

    Meet The Woman Behind London Finance Solutions

    BusinessPeople and Community

Sikh History

When Was the Golden Temple Built - Unveiling the Origins

June 13, 2023
When Was the Golden Temple Built - Unveiling the Origins »

AMAR SHAHEED BABA DEEP SINGH JI

January 26, 2020
AMAR SHAHEED BABA DEEP SINGH JI »

The Father of Fibre Optics

November 18, 2019
The Father of Fibre Optics »

ARDAS

October 18, 2019
ARDAS »

Recently Added

  • Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic?

    Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic?

    December 17, 2025
  • British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords

    British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords

    May 27, 2024
  • Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India's Destiny

    Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India's Destiny

    December 26, 2024
  • Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism's Rich Heritage

    Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism's Rich Heritage

    July 22, 2023

In Business

  • The Father of Fibre Optics

    The Father of Fibre Optics

    November 18, 2019
  • Meet The Woman Behind London Finance Solutions

    Meet The Woman Behind London Finance Solutions

    October 15, 2017
  • Teenager wins backing from 3 wealthy Dragons

    Teenager wins backing from 3 wealthy Dragons

    July 26, 2016
  • Fusion jewellery sparkles across Indo-Western spectrum

    Fusion jewellery sparkles across Indo-Western spectrum

    September 22, 2009

© 2019 Sikhs Online | A project by Mann Matharu |
Images used on this website are subject to copyright of their respective owners