• About Us
  • Advertise
  • Got a Story?
Twitter
Logo
Menu   ≡ ╳
  • News
  • Arts & Culture
  • Sikhi
  • Business
  • History
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • People & Community
  • Matrimonials
Latest:
  • Health & Lifestyle Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic?
  • People and Community British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords
  • News Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India’s Destiny
  • Sikhi Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism’s Rich Heritage
  • Sikhi The Guru Granth Sahib: Sikhism’s Holy Book
  • History When Was the Golden Temple Built – Unveiling the Origins
Judge hits errant dairy with £200k costs
Home » News » Judge hits errant dairy with £200k costs

Judge hits errant dairy with £200k costs

22 July, 2009
News
2598

A High Court battle between two Sikh-owned dairy businesses ended in June with the loser, Johal Dairies of Wolverhampton, facing a legal bill estimated at £1 million.

This week Johal failed in a bid to persuade trial Judge David Cooke to allow it to enter an appeal against his original judgement.

The judge could see no compelling arguments for the appeal nor any real prospect of it succeeding.

He ordered the company to pay rival JN Dairies legal costs, starting with a payment of £200,000 prior to further decisions on costs and compensation.

At the trial, Judge Cooke heard how a milkman sacked by JN Dairies, also of Wolverhampton, was paid £40,000 by Johal to steal confidential documents from his former employers. Johal subsequently paid his fare to India prior to the trial and he took no part in the court case.

The court was told that stolen information about JN customers was used by Johal to approach a number of JN customers with undercutting offers.

The story of the “undercover spy” and the milk wars in Birmingham and the Black Country was revealed at the Birmingham Civil Justice Centre in an eight-day trial in March, with judgement reserved until June.

The firms were competing fiercely to supply independent supermarkets and shops but Johal was found to have acted unlawfully by paying driver Gurbir Singh, an illegal immigrant, to steal the information about JN customers.

Singh committed the act on November 8, two days after being sacked by JN Dairies because he could not prove his legal status in the UK. He sneaked into the firm’s Millfields Road distribution centre at 2am and removed delivery invoices, which detailed confidential addresses, volumes sold and prices charged by the dairy.

The files were passed to a Johal director, Surbjit Johal, the court heard.

JN customers testified that they had been offered cheap or free milk by the firm. One customer was offered four weeks’ milk supply free and another free milk for three months.

The Judge concluded the theft of invoices was a pre-arranged plan, called Johal’s denials implausible and found against the company and Gurbir Singh.

JN Dairies founder and director Jaspal Singh Nijjar was delighted with the outcome. He said: “We do not have a problem with fair competition, and indeed have been successfully competing with Johal Dairies and other companies for a number of years, but unlawful activity to attack our business will not be tolerated by JN Dairies, nor will the law allow anyone to get away with it.”

For Johal, announcing its intention to seek permission to appeal, a spokesman had said the firm was extremely surprised and disappointed by the judgment. It maintained its denial of any wrongdoing and said it would continue with business as normal, confident that it enjoyed the loyal support of customers and suppliers.

Evidence that Johal had been offering customers cut price deals on milk infuriated farmers who supply the so-called “middle market” retailers.

Following the collapse of the giant Dairy Farmers of Britain (DFB) co-operative – many of whose 1,000 or so members were forced to sell milk below the cost of production – the High Court revelations incensed dairy farmers. They believe cut price deals to retailers always exert downward pressure on prices.

  • About the Author
  • Latest Posts

About Mann Matharu

Mann Matharu is the Chief Editor and Founder of Sikhs Online. He is responsible for the research into Sikh related stories and marketing of the site.
  • British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords - May 27, 2024
  • Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India’s Destiny - December 26, 2024
  • Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism’s Rich Heritage - July 22, 2023
  • The Guru Granth Sahib: Sikhism’s Holy Book - July 3, 2023
  • When Was the Golden Temple Built – Unveiling the Origins - June 13, 2023
  • Why do Sikhs wear turbans – Sikhs Online - April 18, 2023
  • Navigating Life with Teachings of Guru Nanak - April 6, 2023
  • Kulveer Ranger’s Biography, Wife, Career, Achievements - April 3, 2023
  • Sidhu Moosewala Biography: Height, Age, First Song and More - March 26, 2023
  • The life of Amrita Sher-Gil: India’s Frida Kahlo - April 15, 2020
Mann Matharu
  • Arts and Culture 26
  • Business 10
  • Health & Lifestyle 21
  • History 30
  • News 140
  • People and Community 87
  • Sikh Videos 2
  • Sikhi 15
  • Uncategorized 9
- Previous article
« Bollywood is ‘escapist dross’ says Times writer
Next article -
Introducing DJ BaLLi »
  • Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic? Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic?
    December 17
    Health & Lifestyle
  • British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords
    May 27
    People and Community
  • Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India’s Destiny Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India’s Destiny
    December 26
    NewsPeople and Community
  • Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism’s Rich Heritage Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism’s Rich Heritage
    July 22
    Sikhi
  • The Guru Granth Sahib: Sikhism’s Holy Book The Guru Granth Sahib: Sikhism’s Holy Book
    July 3
    Sikhi
  • When Was the Golden Temple Built – Unveiling the Origins When Was the Golden Temple Built – Unveiling the Origins
    June 13
    History

  • Why do Sikhs wear turbans – Sikhs Online

    Why do Sikhs wear turbans – Sikhs Online

    Sikhi
  • Top Ten Things That Inspire Me

    Top Ten Things That Inspire Me

    Health & LifestylePeople and Community
  • Meet The Woman Behind London Finance Solutions

    Meet The Woman Behind London Finance Solutions

    BusinessPeople and Community

Sikh History

When Was the Golden Temple Built - Unveiling the Origins

June 13, 2023
When Was the Golden Temple Built - Unveiling the Origins »

AMAR SHAHEED BABA DEEP SINGH JI

January 26, 2020
AMAR SHAHEED BABA DEEP SINGH JI »

The Father of Fibre Optics

November 18, 2019
The Father of Fibre Optics »

ARDAS

October 18, 2019
ARDAS »

Recently Added

  • Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic?

    Mental Health Through the Social Media Filter – Is It Toxic?

    December 17, 2025
  • British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords

    British Sikh Peer Kulveer Ranger Faces Suspension in House of Lords

    May 27, 2024
  • Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India's Destiny

    Manmohan Singh: The Economist Who Reshaped India's Destiny

    December 26, 2024
  • Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism's Rich Heritage

    Sikh Kara: A Glorious Expression of Sikhism's Rich Heritage

    July 22, 2023

In Business

  • The Father of Fibre Optics

    The Father of Fibre Optics

    November 18, 2019
  • Meet The Woman Behind London Finance Solutions

    Meet The Woman Behind London Finance Solutions

    October 15, 2017
  • Teenager wins backing from 3 wealthy Dragons

    Teenager wins backing from 3 wealthy Dragons

    July 26, 2016
  • Fusion jewellery sparkles across Indo-Western spectrum

    Fusion jewellery sparkles across Indo-Western spectrum

    September 22, 2009

© 2019 Sikhs Online | A project by Mann Matharu |
Images used on this website are subject to copyright of their respective owners